How AI assistants recommend insurance brokers

Someone who asks an AI assistant for an insurance broker often hears the largest global brokers first. Here is what the assistants answered in every city the AIGROW Index asked, and what a local broker can work on.

55%AI Visibility Index, November 2026: 4,608 answersof the names came up in one answer only
Cities asked
128
Names in the rankings
1,274
Businesses named per city
43
Names repeated on a rerun
48%
Answers that name the leader
44%
The first two rows are counts; the rows under them are medians over the ranked pages. Every question was asked without a location or a chat history.

Asked for an insurance broker in 128 cities, ChatGPT, Claude and Gemini named about 43 brokers per city, and 55% of those names came up only once. Each assistant builds its list from what is published about a broker. What a broker controls is that public record: its cover, its clients and its listings.

What a customer asked, and who came first

One place of the 128, as an example: New York. Every place was asked the same questions in its own language, and its page in the Index has the full ranking.

  1. Who is the best insurance broker in New York?
  2. I need insurance for my small business in New York. Which broker would you recommend?
  3. Which insurance agency in New York can find me cheaper home and car insurance?
  4. Which independent insurance broker in New York would you recommend to a family?
  1. HUB Internationalnamed in 44% of the answers
  2. NFPnamed in 31% of the answers
  3. Brown & Brown Insurancenamed in 31% of the answers
The full ranking

The names that recur

68 different businesses came first across 128 rankings, and 220 names were listed in three places or more. These are the most frequent.

  • Aon58 places
  • Marsh45 places
  • Allianz32 places
  • Gallagher26 places
  • AXA23 places
  • HUB International22 places

Counted by spelling: two businesses with the same name in different places count as one.

What an owner can work on

No one can promise a place in an assistant’s answer. What an owner controls is what is published about the business, and these are the parts the questions above point to.

Say who you insure

The questions come from a small business, a family and someone looking for cheaper home and car insurance. A page for each kind of client, with the cover you arrange, answers each question as it is asked.

Say that you are independent

One question asked for an independent broker. If you are one, say so plainly, with the insurers you work with, on your site and in every listing.

Registration that can be checked

Your registration as a broker, listed the same way on your site and in the public register, is a fact an assistant can repeat and a client can verify.

See what the assistants say about your business.

The free checker asks the questions a customer would ask and shows who gets named. The audit goes further: your own questions, four assistants, and the fixes in the order they matter.

The audit: $190 once · within 5 working days or refunded